Phase 1 Narrative

When beginning a project investigation, teachers enthusiastically brainstorm learning possibilities that may arise from studying a topic. Together they generate a concept map (Teacher Topic Web) that may include activities across disciplines, resources, big ideas, required curricular objectives, and basic skills. Sometimes, teachers take note of children's interests and begin their investigation with a child-initiated event. Other times, the teacher predetermines a broad topic that gets narrowed after the children have had an opportunity to brainstorm their ideas.

The first phase of a project is designed to uncover what the children already know about a topic and to establish a common ground. The project began when children saw a number of events at the construction site near the school and reported them at the first group meeting.

In order to capture their current level of understanding and knowledge of construction, the children brainstormed their ideas about construction from their own experiences on the second day of the project. The teacher wrote the ideas on 'post-it' notes. On the next day, each child revisited his/her ideas, explained them further and noted the similarities of their ideas to those of their classmates. Together the teachers and students grouped similar responses into categories. Children delved into analytical thinking to explain how they wanted their ideas categorized.

CM: I think cranes should go with bulldozers because they are the same. They lift things.
BG: I disagree. Cranes are not the same as bulldozers because the crane has that thing that lifts that makes it different.
CM: They are the same, they do the same things. They just have different names.
JJ: Cranes knock down buildings and so do bulldozers. So they are the same.
WJ: Cranes help scoop up rocks.
Jay: Yeah. Bulldozers can't scoop, they are just for pushing things.
CM: Well they are all machines that work on constructions.
AH: We could put tractors, machines, cranes all together. They are all machines.
Teacher: What do you think? AH is suggesting that all the machines go together in the same group.
WJ: No, I think the cranes should be separate from the others.
NO: Yeah.
HB: I know that the construction workers start to build from the top. I see them up high.
JP: I think the first step to build a building is to dig a hole.
ER: Yeah, the museum dinosaur workers that I saw did the roof last.

Children argued and debated the best name for the categories. JN remembered that structures have attics and JH knew some houses had basements. JH suggested that they should be categorized together. JN wanted the category to be called the attic group. JH insisted it couldn't be called the attic group because his idea was about basements and that title wouldn't include his idea. These discussions revealed current concepts, understandings and misunderstandings that became opportunities for growth and learning. Once they finalized their decisions, their ideas were visually represented on a topic web (Construction Topic Web I).

To encourage students to share their own stories about their previous experiences with construction, the Head teacher shared stories and pictures of her husband repairing the barn on her farm. Then in a whole group meeting she asked each of them to think of a personal story about construction. Some children shared their stories during the group meeting.

The next day, each had thought of a story. They drew and wrote (or dictated to a teacher) about their personal experiences. They chose ways to represent what they already knew. They drew and painted buildings under construction. "The roof was being built on my house." Nicholas' memory of building a house.

"The roof was being built on my house."
          
Nicholas' memory of building a house.

They also made 3-dimensional models of construction using clay, legos, blocks, sand, rods, boxes and junk, and paper. AH has constructed a basket and is writing how she made it.


AH has constructed a basket and is writing how she made it.

The children shared their project experience stories and representations, once again noting similarities (Calendar day 7). The stories were categorized, labeled and displayed on the wall in a graph.

The students gathered data about what other children in the class already knew. They asked classmates, "Are cranes the same as bulldozers?" Six children said "yes." Fifteen said "no." With the children, the teacher put the raw data into a graphic organizer to visually show what the class knew about these machines. Their misconceptions became opportunities for investigation.

          
Sign-in question: Are cranes the same as bulldozers?
 
Pie graph organizing the data.

Children raised many questions during the discussions. These were recorded on a chart as the children expressed them. Any additional questions were added. The categorized the questions into 5 groups that formed the study teams for Phase 2. Some questions were overarching ones that raised big ideas and suggested complexity for investigation for the whole group. The researchable questions gave direction to Phase 2 of the project.

Big Ideas

WJ  What is construction for?
CS  How do they talk people into letting them crash down buildings to build other buildings?
KK  Why do they need skyscrapers? What is the relationship between building and repair, construction and the environment? (From the Teachers' Topic Web)


What are the names and kinds of machines that are used for constructions?

Machines
EA  Why is the crane there?
AH  Why do they have all those machines?
ER  Why are tall cranes taller than small cranes?
JN  How do people control steamrollers?
KS  How do cranes and bulldozers do the same thing?
JB  How do they make the big machines?
LM  How do cranes hook on to the roof?
AM  How does a bulldozer and crane lift heavy things?
JB  How do you build equipment to make things?


What kinds of materials do builders use?

Materials
JH  How do they make the floor?
BG  How do they know there are broken wires under the ground?
JJ  How do they make bumpy rocks flat for the floors of a house - the concrete?
NC  How do you decide what type of floors go inside buildings?


What are all of the kinds of buildings that are constructed?

Kinds of Buildings
CO  Why aren't houses the same?
AH  Why can't all houses be all in one color inside and outside?
AK  Why can't houses be the same color?
MA  Are skyscrapers taller than cranes?


What are the parts that make up buildings?

Parts of Buildings
JF  Why are there designs on doors?
CO  Why is there always a porch in front of the door?
KK  Why does every house have two doors?
CM  Why don't they put doors in different spots?
AK  Why do some houses have attics and basements and some don't?
AH  How do people make stained glass windows?
KK  Why do you need glass windows?
CM  Why do they need screens on windows?
NO  How do they get different colors on some glass? (like stained glass)
SL  How do they make glass to put on windows?
JB  How do they put windows inside cars?
NO  How do they get lamps into ceilings?


How many different types of roofs are used on buildings? (Roofs)

Roofs
NC  Why do you have roofs on top?
SJ  How do they build roofs?
SL  How do they build chimneys?
HB  I wonder about why houses have roofs.
JP  How do they build up roofs?


   
Return to Construction
Table of Contents
  


STUDYING
CONSTRUCTION
 
EXPLORING
COMMUNICATION

© 2001. University Primary School. Department of Special Education. University of Illinois.
All rights reserved. Credits.